The Minister of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy is not generating enough of the desired investment in public-private research through the PPP Innovation Scheme (PPP = Public-Private Partnership). The minister intends to award a total of €650-700 million in grants under the scheme from 2024 to 2027. However, the grants are allocated inefficiently and therefore do not generate enough of the desired R&D investment from the public and private sectors. At the same time, the target of spending 3% of GDP on R&D has not been met for years.
The Netherlands Court of Audit states this in its report Innovation subsidy under scrutiny, published today. This audit focuses specifically on the PPP Innovation Scheme, one of the ministry's largest instruments for promoting public-private R&D and innovation. The minister intends to revise this scheme with effect from 1 January 2028, as there is scope to improve its current implementation. The allocation of future grants could also be made more efficient.
The PPP Innovation Scheme is currently not generating enough of the desired business investment in R&D. This is partly because the current allocation of grants is not aligned with the innovation priorities set by the minister in late 2023. These include key technologies, climate and energy, digitalisation and the circular economy. In 2024, over half of the combined total of more than €270 million in grants and private contributions went towards other innovation themes.
More than half of grants and private contributions (over € 270 million) were not allocated to the innovation priorities of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy
Grants and private contributions (€ millions)
This bar chart shows the total amount of grant funding and private contributions in the 2024 grant year. The bar shows how the funding was distributed across the Knowledge and Innovation Agendas. It reveals that more than half of the funding was not allocated to the innovation priorities of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy. These priorities are key technologies, climate and energy, digitalisation and the circular economy. The vast majority of the grant funding in 2024 went towards health and healthcare as well as agriculture, water and food.
Moreover, the design of the subsidy scheme poses significant risks to efficiency. This is because the grants are distributed through 12 so-called Top Consortia for Knowledge and Innovation (TKIs). Notably, substantial amounts of funding go to TKIs where private contributions lag behind. In fact, 48% of the grants go to TKIs that, on average, require twice as much grant funding as other TKIs to generate private investment in public-private partnership research. This means that the allocation of grants is inefficient in terms of encouraging private contributions to research.
Some TKIs require relatively large amounts of grant funding under the PPP Innovation Scheme to generate contributions from businesses
Grant funding under the PPS Innovation Scheme required to generate €1 in contributions from businesses
This chart shows how much grant funding is required for each Top Consortium for Knowledge and Innovation (TKI) to generate €1 in business investment in public-private partnership research. It shows that relatively large amounts of grant funding are required for most TKIs. For example, TKI Energy requires more than €2.50 in grant funding to generate €1 in private investment. For TKI Agri and Food, the amount is less than €1. Eight of the 12 TKIs require more than €1.50 in grant funding to generate €1 in business investment in public-private partnership research.
By allocating the grants differently, the minister could not only focus more strongly on current innovation priorities but also generate more public-private partnership research overall.
Recommendations
Under the current PPP Innovation Scheme, approximately €170 million in grants remains to be allocated in 2027. The Netherlands Court of Audit recommends that the minister examine the extent to which there is still scope under the current scheme to influence how these grants are spent, so that the funding can be used to support the government's innovation priorities as effectively as possible. For the new scheme, it is recommended that provision be made for periodic adjustments to the budget and the allocation of grants.